From repositories supported by communities to communities supported by repositories

Issues and lessons learned

Abstract

The Carrick Institute for Teaching and Learning in Higher Education is developing the Carrick Exchange to provide a forum for sharing resources and expertise about learning and teaching. This paper reflects on relevant experience in North America with related initiatives, which highlight (a number of) issues to be considered and (a few) lessons which can be incorporated in the design and development of the Carrick Exchange.

Most of the experience cited here comes from the MERLOT network, including both the MERLOT discipline community Editorial Boards and related communities such as the Cooperative Learning Object Exchange in Canada, the disciplinary Teaching Commons sites within the California State University, and the new MERLOT Innovation Projects such as ELIXR creating reusable resources for staff development.

This paper also analyses the resulting reflections in the context of an independently-developed taxonomy for distributed collaborations in a parallel domain: large-scale scientific collaboratories. This analysis suggests that a full range of possibilities needs to be explored across dimensions such as aggregation versus co-creation and the range of valuable contributions of resources, information and knowledge. Another conclusion is that a number of user needs can be met without the full infrastructure of a distributed community of practice.