Skip to main content

Unpacking your Case: The Case Study as a Research Methodology

PDF A Threshold-Based Self-Diagnostic Scorecard

Abstract

Case study research is widely used in higher education scholarship yet remains a misunderstood and inconsistently applied research methodology. Many manuscripts labelled as case studies are more accurately characterised as reflective accounts, practice examples, or descriptive vignettes, risking a limitation of methodological rigour and scholarly contribution. This editorial examines the characteristics of case study methodology and the distinctions between research case studies and other forms of educational inquiry. Drawing on established methodological literature, we outline the hallmarks of rigorous case study research, including alignment between research questions and methods, clearly bounded cases, transparent analytical pathways, and the use of multiple sources of evidence. We consider common methodological challenges, including overreliance on description, misunderstanding of transferability and generalisability, weak theoretical integration, and insufficient methodological transparency. We explore how educators can move from local practice-based observations to scholarly contributions through analytic generalisation and contextualised interpretation. We present a practical self-diagnostic scorecard supporting pre-submission readiness of case study manuscripts. By clarifying expectations and promoting rigour, this editorial seeks to strengthen the quality, credibility, and impact of case study research.

Keywords

Research methods, case study research, methodological rigour, analytic generalisation, transferability.