Skip to main content

Designing learning analytics with care: A multiple case study approach

PDF

Abstract

Learning analytics (LA) in higher education has been shaped primarily by compliance-based ethical frameworks. We argue this is insufficient to govern the relational dimensions of data-driven practice. This paper proposes the Care-Centred Learning Analytics Design Standard (CLADS), a framework that reorients LA system design around the ethics of care tradition developed by Gilligan, Noddings, and Tronto. CLADS is organised around five principles — Relationality, Transparency and Mutual Visibility, Contextual Sensitivity, Equity of Care, Participatory Design and Ongoing Co-Creation. Each is grounded in care ethics theory and each carries concrete design implications. Empirical grounding is provided by a qualitative multiple case study conducted across five demographically diverse Australian universities, in which 23 participants were interviewed and findings analysed using template analysis structured around the CLADS principles. The study finds that while existing LA practice frequently demonstrates care-aligned sensibilities at the operational level, the structural and governance commitments necessary to make care reliable, equitable, and visible remain largely absent. CLADS offers a principled design standard to address that gap.

Keywords

Learning analytics, ethics of care, care-centred design, higher education, student equity, participatory design.

Author Biography

  • Dr David Tuffley, Griffith University
    A globally recognised technology communicator, David has spent decades at the intersection of human culture and digital disruption, reaching tens of millions worldwide through platforms such as The Conversation, The Washington Post, The Chicago Tribune, and major national and international broadcasters. Renowned for making complex ideas both accessible and compelling, he brings together scholarly rigour and a powerful storytelling instinct, engaging audiences from the World Science Festival to corporate boardrooms and university lecture theatres. Beyond his extensive portfolio of more than 100 non-fiction works—spanning cybersecurity, AI ethics, classical rhetoric, and architectural history—David is also an accomplished composer and musician. He is a Senior Fellow of the Higher Education Academy at Griffith University, and with a strong foundation in applied ethics and cybersecurity, has built a reputation for pedagogical innovation, successfully convening courses for over 600 students annually across multiple campuses and online platforms.