Skip to main content

Between risk and reform: Learning designers’ experiences of institutional responses to GenAI in assessment

PDF

Abstract

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has prompted universities to reconsider how assessment can remain meaningful, valid and fit for an AI-integrated future. While institutional responses to GenAI are often framed as technical, policy or academic integrity challenges, they are also deeply human organisational change challenges, shaped by competing logics of risk, reform, infrastructure and operational efficiency. Drawing on semi-structured interviews with 11 learning designers (LDs) from six Australian and New Zealand universities, the paper addresses the following research question: How do LDs experience and navigate institutional responses to GenAI in assessment in higher education? The analysis identified five interrelated themes: navigating strategic ambiguity and policy lag; mediating compliance-driven and integrity-focused responses; translating GenAI disruption into assessment reform; bridging AI infrastructure and pedagogical practice; and advocating for educational purpose within operational constraints. The paper contributes to current debates on GenAI and assessment by shifting attention from assessment tasks and technologies to the institutional conditions that shape assessment change. It argues that in addition to policy statements and enterprise AI platforms, sustainable responses to GenAI require coordinated professional development, curriculum governance processes enabling timely change, and stronger recognition of LDs as strategic partners whose pedagogical expertise, institutional knowledge and change leadership are central to assessment transformation.

Keywords

Generative AI, assessment design, learning designers, higher education, qualitative.

Author Biographies

  • Dr Nhung Nguyen, University of Tasmania

    Dr Nhung Nguyen is Senior Lecturer in Learning and Teaching at The University of Tasmania. She is a passionate educator with twenty years of experience in digital technologies in education, science education, learning design, and academic development. Nhung previously worked as a principal learning designer, educational designer, and a lecturer in education and physics. She is currently teaching units of the Monash Graduate Certificate of Educational Design. Nhung has won Teaching Excellence Awards 2024-2026 - Monash Online, CAULLT Peer’s Choice Award in Academic Development 2024, and ASCILITE Emerging Scholar Award 2024 for leadership, mentorship (learning designers) and research.

  • Prof Michael Henderson, Monash University

    Prof Michael Henderson is Professor of Higher Education and Digital Futures in the Faculty of Education at Monash University. He has been teaching educational design for 15 years and created the Graduate Certificate of Educational Design, and Australia’s first Bachelor degree in Learning Design and Technology.

  • Associate Professor Keith Heggart, University of Wollongong

    Associate Professor Keith Heggart, University of Wollongong. He has worked in education and educational leadership roles in Australia and England, as well as running his own learning design consultancy. He developed UTS’s award-winning Graduate Certificate in Learning Design.

  • Dr Homa Babai, Monash University

    Dr Homa Babai is a Lecturer in Learning Design and Technology at Monash University. She teaches in the Bachelor of Learning Design and Technology and Graduate Certificate of Educational Design programs. Having worked as a learning designer, she has extensive experience in curriculum design, development and enhancement. She has received prestigious teaching and learning awards in higher education. Her research focuses on learning design as a professional field including the practices, capabilities, and impact of learning designers across contexts.