Skip to main content

Rebalancing the algorithm: The educational technologist as an ecosystem custodian

PDF

Abstract

This paper is a conceptual position paper grounded in a decade of research into the values and beliefs of educational technologists (McNutt, 2019). It proposes that three interconnected concepts – Universal Design, ecosystem custodianship, and the poetic imagination offer a framework to inform and guide conversations and discussions on rebalancing the algorithm in the field of educational technology. The profession is standing at a crossroads as algorithmic systems are marginalising human judgement. There is an opportunity for educational technologists to assert their identity as ecosystem custodians – by cultivating environments where technological innovation, inclusive practice and human dignity remain in productive balance. The CONFRONT framework, originally presented at the EAN Conference (Craddock & McNutt, 2025) is anchored in eight poetic principles (Communicate, Opportunities, Nurture, Feel, Reduce, Ownership, Nudge, Trust), is proposed as a practical and philosophical architecture for that work. The paper’s one central argument, to quote Seamus Heaney, “If you have the words there is always a chance that you will find the way,” at its best, the algorithm should serve our poem, not the other way round.

Keywords

Academic teacher beliefs, artificial intelligence, universal design, poetry, CONFRONT framework, inclusive design, conceptual.

Author Biography

  • Larry McNutt, Technological University Dublin (retired)

    Dr. Larry McNutt is a former Registrar of TU Dublin–Blanchardstown - Ireland and a Fellow of the Irish Computer Society. With over 40 years in higher education leadership and research, his expertise spans universal design, instructional design, and educational technology. He remains an active contributor to academic discourse nationally and internationally.