Skip to main content

Supporting ethical engagement with AI in education: Evaluating the ethical coverage of the Scaffolded AI Literacy (SAIL) framework

PDF

Abstract

Ethical engagement with AI in education requires more than awareness of risks or compliance with institutional policy. Educators and learners need to recognise, evaluate, mitigate, and respond to ethical issues as AI tools become embedded in learning and teaching. This paper examines whether the Scaffolded AI Literacy (SAIL) framework provides a sufficiently comprehensive set of competencies for this purpose. Six cross-sector systematic reviews and mappings of AI ethics are analysed to provide a benchmark of recurring ethical issues identified in relation to AI. The comparison shows strong coverage in the SAIL framework of issues including fairness, equity, transparency, privacy and safety. Human agency, accountability, well-being, human rights, and participation are partially addressed but less explicit. Notably, environmental sustainability demonstrates the clearest gap between emphasis in the literature and explicit coverage in the framework. The analysis supports SAIL as a substantial framework for ethical AI literacy while identifying targeted opportunities for refinement.

Keywords

AI ethics, AI literacy, Framework, SAIL, Bias, cultural diversity.

Author Biographies

  • Dr. David Parsons, academyEX

    Research Director at academyEX and Adjunct Professor at the University of Canterbury

  • Professor Kathryn MacCallum, University of Canterbury
    Professor and Head of School of Leadership and Professional Practice and Co-Director of the Digital Education Futures Research Lab (Te Puna Rangahau i-Ako), University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand