The rapid emergence of generative artificial intelligence (AI) presents significant challenges in higher education, often leading to student dependency and educator “AI fatigue.” Despite policy calls for assessment reform, practical, evidence-based approaches to developing critical AI literacy remain limited. This paper addresses this gap by presenting a practice-based curriculum case study and reflective inquiry investigating the structural redesign of a multidisciplinary Information and Communications Technology (ICT) unit. Moving away from surveillance and AI detection, the curriculum was redesigned to decompose high-stakes assessments into a scaffolded, low-stakes formative feedback sequence. Employing a Reflective Teaching Practice (RTP) methodology grounded in Schön’s reflective practitioner framework, the inquiry evaluates this curriculum redesign through the educator’s professional reflective diary and theoretical student persona modelling. Theoretical learning archetypes were constructed to evaluate how the scaffolded structures support diverse student AI literacy profiles. Educator reflective logs highlighted strategies for managing AI dependency and inflated expectations around AI, suggesting that scaffolded AI literacy and personally relevant assessments helped mitigate cognitive offloading. Ultimately, this inquiry suggests that navigating the AI landscape requires a return to foundational, compassionate pedagogical principles, prioritising continuous feedback and structured self-reflection to support positioning AI as a meaningful learning opportunity rather than a disruptive academic burden.
Keywords
AI literacy, Reflective practice, Feedback, academic integrity, higher education, reflective case study.
Author Biographies
Dr Gitte Galea, CQ University
Dr Gitte Galea is a Lecturer in Information and Communications Technology (ICT) within the School of Engineering and Technology at CQUniversity, teaching across the ICT Foundations and Information Systems & Analysis disciplines. With over 20 years of industry experience and active research interests in educational technologies, information systems, ethics, and organisational practice, she brings a strong focus on people-centred, pedagogically informed approaches to technology in both education and industry.
Professor Michael A. Cowling, RMIT University
Professor Michael A. Cowling is Director of the Hub for Apple Platform Innovation (HAPI) and Professor of Educational Technology in the School of Computing Technologies, STEM College, RMIT University. He is a leader in educational technology, digital innovation, and technology-enhanced learning, with extensive experience advancing teaching, learning, and research through the effective use of emerging technologies.