Skip to main content

EAL/D students’ constructions of agency in AI technology-assisted learning environments: A case from the field of media and communication studies

PDF

Abstract

The use of generative AI (GenAI) technologies has become increasingly prevalent across Australian higher education. As these tools become an integral part of learning, they also raise concerns about over-reliance and learner agency (Resnick, 2024), authorship, ownership, and problematic forms of co-creation (Bozkurt, 2024). In Australia, 31% of the student population identify as having English as an additional language or dialect (EAL/D) (Australian Government Department of Education, 2024). Apart from cultural and linguistic challenges, EAL/D students also need to adapt to new academic expectations and practices that account for the impacts of GenAI technologies (Kebble, 2023). Given the unique challenges facing EAL/D student cohorts with their diverse pre-existing technological backgrounds, a gap exists in understanding how EAL/D students perceive their own work and academic contributions in relation to their use of GenAI tools. This study explores EAL/D students’ AI-assisted learning experiences and perspectives on agency through qualitative interviews conducted with 34 Master of Digital Communication students over 18 months. Findings suggest that EAL/D students are instinctively adjusting and adapting their learning practices as they engage with these technologies and making agentic decisions that support their learning. To maintain what they considered to be original and creative in their work, students developed several strategies to distinguish their own work from AI-generated output. We also found that as EAL/D students’ engagement with AI increases, they develop critical self-scrutiny. They maintain agency and ownership over their assessed work by ensuring that their (human) creativity remains central throughout the learning process.  While there are some commonalities, the students in our study took diverse paths, with some students developing more nuanced and balanced approaches to using AI than others. For these students, the shift enabled them to integrate GenAI strategically while maintaining their own voice and sense of agency.

Keywords

English as an additional language or dialect (EAL/D), generative AI, agency, student, learning, experience, ownership.

Author Biographies

  • Xiaoting Yu, Queensland University of Technology

     

    Dr Xiaoting Yu is an affiliate investigator of Digital Media Research Centre, Queensland University of Technology. She is also teaching communication theories and media industries courses across QUT’s undergraduate and postgraduate programs. Her pedagogical approach is informed by her research in creator cultures, platform studies and media management. By integrating contemporary and global perspectives into the curriculum,  Xiaoting seeks to engage students to critically examine the influence of technology in media industries and creative labour. 

  • Michelle Riedlinger, Queensland University of Technology

    Dr Michelle Riedlinger is an Associate Professor and a Chief Investigator in the Digital Media Research Centre at the Queensland University of Technology and an associate investigator in the ARC Centre of Excellence for Automated Decision-Making and Society. Her research interests include emerging research communication practices, online fact checking, and generative authenticity in the knowledge industries. She collaborates with a team of researchers considering the impacts of GenAI on the scholar economy, building on the teams’ past research efforts investigating the platformisation of research discovery, critical digital literacy in academic environments, and AI’s cultures of use.