Skip to main content

Reading the cards: Rebalancing the algorithm in higher education

PDF

Abstract

Higher education continues to navigate uncertainty created by the emergence of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI). Institutional responses have largely focused on assessment reform, educational integrity and governance. This conceptual paper frames GenAI as a wicked problem and considers institutional responses as acts of sensemaking through which universities establish shared understandings and guide actions. Drawing on tarot as an interpretive lens, we introduce eight archetypes as a conceptual framework for examining higher education’s response to GenAI. The archetypes were selected for their conceptual resonance with higher education’s response to GenAI, the productive tension between the traditional and shadow meanings, and their recognisable symbolism. Organised across three dimensions – encountering uncertainty, seeking certainty and rebalancing educational values – the framework traces readings from The Fool, The Magician, The Tower, through to The Emperor, Justice, to The High Priestess, The Lovers and The Star. This reading highlights the prominence of disruption, governance and regulation in current responses while bringing wisdom, relationships and hope clearly into view. We argue that rebalancing the algorithm requires educational values to guide GenAI integration. The framework offers an accessible way to surface different perspectives, support collective sensemaking and open dialogue about the educational futures being created.

Keywords

GenAI, higher education, wicked problems, relational pedagogy, educational futures.

Author Biographies

  • Dr Justine Maldon, Edith Cowan University

    Dr Justine Maldon (SFHEA) is the acting Manager, Learning Support at the Centre for Learning and Teaching at Edith Cowan University and President of the Association of Academic Language and Learning. She is passionate about teaching excellence and promoting student engagement and success in higher education. Justine has expertise in developing interactive, student-centred courses and has received a Vice Chancellor's Award for Initiatives that Enhance Student Learning, specifically for her work with the First Year Experience. She holds a PhD from the University of Western Australia and is experienced in teaching and learning research, utilising both qualitative and quantitative methods.

  • Michelle Pedlow, The University of Western Australia

    Michelle Pedlow (SFHEA) is the Curriculum Strategy and Educational Innovation Lead for the Department of Nursing at The University of Western Australia. Her work focuses on the design and implementation of innovative, student-centred curricula that prepare future nurses for complex and dynamic healthcare environments. Michelle’s research interests include programmatic assessment, feedback literacy, and technology-enhanced learning. She is particularly passionate about creating inclusive learning experiences that support regional, remote, and diverse student cohorts. In 2018, she received the Vice-Chancellor’s Staff Award for Contribution to Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander Advancement at Edith Cowan University, recognising her work in developing a culturally safe nursing curriculum.