Abstract
Much of the development of a physical skill occurs outside formal instruction, and practitioners often turn to resources such as video to guide their own learning. Yet how practitioners move from watching a technique to performing it, and where that process breaks down, has received little attention. This paper examines self-directed embodied learning in Brazilian jiu-jitsu, a grappling sport where technique is learned through physical practice against a resisting partner. Through semi-structured interviews with ten experienced practitioners, analysed using reflexive thematic analysis, we contribute an empirical account of self-directed embodied learning with video, and a conceptual model of how video study and partnered practice relate. Practitioners used video in three roles: as instruction, as a record of real performance, and as material for self-review—but they consistently set a boundary around it. Video conveys what a technique looks like, not what it feels like, and making a technique usable requires practice against a resisting partner that video does not provide. Interpreted through self-regulated learning theory, these findings imply three requirements for technology in embodied skill domains: support self-review, adapt to the individual, and accept that some parts of learning can only happen with a partner on the mat.
Keywords
Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu, Self-directed learning, Self-regulated learning, video-based learning, embodied skill development, extended reality, reflexive thematic analysis.
