Skip to main content

Friction by design – desirable difficulty in AI co-learning

PDF

Abstract

AI is only the latest in a succession of educational technologies that have made learning easier and more frictionless, which, counterintuitively, has coincided with a population-level decline in cognitive ability and poor learning outcomes. Studies in cognitive offloading and productive struggle suggest it may be affordances of information technology exacerbated by AI that contribute to these poor outcomes. Describing the relevance of cognitive offloading, cognitive load theory and the expertise reversal effect, this paper explores the cognitive mechanisms associated with technological assistance that have been shown to affect learning, and considers pathways to redesign learning in a way that focuses on useful forms of learning friction, understood as the effortful work that consolidates learning. The paper locates these cognitive mechanisms near the learner experience where self-regulation holds the most potential to effect change when combined with educator support. The question for educators, designers and students will continue to evolve: does experiencing friction enhance learning? A heuristic is offered as a conceptual model of a process for teachers and designers to support learners at the point where cognitive offloading occurs.

Keywords

Cognitive offloading, desirable difficulty, productive struggle, generative AI, friction, learning design.

Author Biography

  • Daniel Laurence, Victoria University

    Dan Laurence has worked at a range of universities as a senior learning designer, technologist, researcher and occasional teacher. In 2015 and again in 2017 he was awarded the Vice Chancellor’s Teaching Excellence award at Swinburne University, and again in 2019 the Vice Chancellor's Teaching Award at La Trobe University. His work was awarded the national 2017 AFR Educational Technology Award and a finalist in the 2022 ASCILITE Battle of the LMS. An assemblage of pedagogical, design, usability and technology expertise continues to inspire the collaborative design of quality student experiences.