Abstract
Peer feedback is widely used in higher education to support evaluative judgement, feedback literacy, and collaborative learning. While previous research has examined either the structural patterns of peer feedback or the characteristics of feedback comments, comparatively little is known about how these dimensions interact within peer learning networks. This study addresses this gap by integrating Social Network Analysis (SNA) with feedback characteristics to examine peer feedback during postgraduate group presentations. Data were collected from 267 students organised into 91 presentation groups across nine tutorials. Directed peer feedback networks were analysed using measures of participation, reciprocity, density, and clustering, while feedback characteristics were examined using text-based indicators of elaboration and sentiment. The findings showed substantial variation in participation and network connectedness across tutorials, with some groups occupying peripheral positions and others forming highly reciprocal learning communities. Groups contributing proportionally more feedback produced longer comments, whereas structural centrality was not associated with feedback length or tone. Integrating structural and content-based analyses provides a more comprehensive understanding of peer feedback than examining either perspective alone. The findings have practical implications for assessment design, feedback literacy, and learning analytics to support more equitable and connected peer learning environments.
Keywords
Peer feedback, feedback literacy, learning analytics, peer learning, higher education, SNA.
