Abstract
Creative disciplines are often organised around shared making, critique and co-present studio practice. This concise paper explores a foundational undergraduate photography course redesigned as an asynchronous, online creative learning space in Vietnam. Drawing on focus group data from 15 students, the paper explores how students experienced autonomy, instructor presence and peer learning in a digital studio environment. Findings suggest that students valued flexibility, self-paced practice and instructor feedback, but peer critique remained cautious and design dependent. Rather than treating this as a deficit, the paper argues that participation in asynchronous creative education is culturally and relationally situated. Digital tools can support creative expression, but they do not automatically generate the trust, legitimacy or shared language required for critique. The paper introduces participatory safety in online, asynchronous creative education as a design principle for intentionally scaffolding critique, visibility, and relational trust. It also outlines key design implications for asynchronous creative learning environments, including structured critique language, small-group peer exchange, instructor-modelled feedback and gradual movement from teacher-led to peer-supported creative dialogue.
Keywords
Asynchronous learning, creative education, photography education, peer critique, qualitative case study, teaching presence, participatory safety.
