Skip to main content

Comparing the positive and negative impacts of AI: A large-scale study of student perspectives

PDF

Abstract

Higher education students are incorporating generative artificial intelligence into many aspects of their studies, yet the ways they judge its positive and negative impacts remain poorly understood. Using qualitative content analysis supported by code-frequency analysis, this paper examines open-ended comments from 2,802 participants drawn from a survey of 8,021 students across four Australian universities. Reported impacts clustered around four themes: study practices, quality, efficiency, and institutional practices. Positive impacts were more frequently coded overall, particularly when students described using AI to support their own study practices and efficiency. Negative responses centred on the inaccuracy of AI outputs. Although relatively few participants commented on institutional teaching and assessment practices, these responses were predominantly negative. The findings suggest that students value AI not only for the quality of its outputs, but also for its role in helping them begin, continue, refine, and complete academic work. Rather than uncritically accepting or categorically rejecting AI, students appeared to make situated judgements about its usefulness and limitations, shaped by concerns about accuracy and trust, as well as by the agency and control they retained over its use. Institutional responses should therefore engage with the complexity of students’ practices and the conditions under which they perceive AI to be useful or problematic.

Keywords

AI, artificial intelligence, studying, study practices, higher education, thematic analysis.

Author Biography

  • Jack Walton, Deakin University

    Dr Jack Walton is a Lecturer in the Centre for Research in Assessment and Digital Learning (CRADLE), Deakin University. He is interested in the ways students and educators come to know quality, how they express themselves in situations where quality matters, and how formal education helps and/or hinders these ways of knowing and creating. His work challenges prevailing norms around assessment, positioning subjectivity as a crucial element of quality assessment design. His current projects trouble the involvement of AI in higher education assessment, and problematise the role of judgement in learning at university.